Anandabazar Patrika

Anandabazar Patrika - Editorial

28 cSArc 1411 }AyyS} 14 vMzG} 2004

<y ...

Pcv PcA} v, y

KvArc {~MySu Y} S |>SMt} cSMi yMhM `Twq
r>S}S AyS~ dS yMc PzSm AtMMiv XsvHAr Y}
Z}Sc |$ |>SMt} cSMi yMhM `Twq r>S}S Ayw~ dS
PcA}Mc PzSm AtMMiv wMyS PzSmS}Mt} dS
PyA, rSZ y AjMrMiv A~dMiv

K{H fmc

_c YM{A}cSv yMc AjMa cM}Ai~S{, YS, PrS{SMt} PtM vSeA}cMt} XAucS} Y} yASSuHvrS AvM _r YM~ShvS, Ac AyMt vHAr} PM PrS{}S _ My} _McySM} PrSSS c} vS Pcv y~ PrS, P AzMrvS{Z PSc Y} ~SArv YM{A}cS PrS{SMt} Xver _cvScMt} cHArc~SwZ PSc! Y{S} y y~~, \}mS dy PSjS, aMt} PrS PzSm PvZ

YM{A}cS} SEArc }SWwAr AvyShMv} <M csSmS {Mv w~ YM{A}cS} AyMt vHAr} <zSy c{MyA y PtM} {SvM} awM}Z wM, Ac Y{S} y} zSS, aMt} PrS PzSm PvZ sScM~, AyAz7 YjSArc cSeMj <cSAr {HS} x~ Xv|SH jj oAB\ y PcSva zSMyZ AjrMrv vS _{vcH Z}Sc |M$ YM{A}cS} <uSv H AMmMva yM} PsMc PcA} XMvc `q PyA jvA<

PzSm |SMt} YMi, rSMt} csS YA eqr AvM hSAhM~} \$Ar wA}Ahr: It has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried. YM{A}cS} _Z AvyShMv} wA}M<AMr Xy er cMc Atv uM} eqr AvM hSAhM~}Z Xv _cCm \$Ar {SsS f}Mi: The best argument against democracy is a five minute conversation with the average voter.

YM{A}cS} _Z XSzSM}j PzSmS} Pc? cH r@S} zSyvSAhS? yMc |>S}S PzSm AtMMiv r@SMt} 75% AyS cM}v, Z}SMc eq-Ay)H XV Ai~, Y} SS{ dMv Y~ cStSMc <r zSMy {tr AtMMiv PcA}} {scMt} PM Cnc \MS Y}a YZ| ySwS}, yM} {scMt} _Z {rS{r cMc {S YMe} _cCm {HS wSaS xM~} M <S _c, |Ata _} {Mu r>SMt}Z PtM} tCm }cSA} cA{Mv} A}MwSm PyA}MMi (A YZ _-} Duelfer Report a 9/11 Commssion-_} A}MwSm) |SMr A&uSHv zSMy y~S MMi, _ tCm yMy} {sMv PcSva <{Sq P{M~Av _ AvM eq{Su{`M~SMr |Ms hhSa MMi YM~ eq{Su{`A~ PrS Av}Mw zSMy rs Pw cM} vS {HS PtdS PeMi, CmAz} tc}S PcSv hSMvM~ dy} PtMdv rS} <uSv Avc ~ r>SMt} }SjNvArc {r P|{v, A}wSyA~cSv tM~} {sc}S wi2 cM}v xi CmAz Y} PoM{SSCmc tM~} {sMc}S A _v _v, A Ay _ ZrSAt _cZ dy} cr Y~StS zSMy wA}Myv c}S |S rS _Z hSMv~`M~S vS PtdM~ AyS c}S |S vS ySwS}mS Xy y PtMZ c{MyA YMi {Mv YMi, `j}SMr tSS} {M aZ }SMj} Y|A~c zSS} cSej`A~ Y} yzS}rH ZM}Aj zSS} cSej`A~ _cZ fmvS crmS Y~StS zSMy wA}Myv c}Ai~

yM} {scMt} _cmS y X AyMt vHAr AyM _Z u}Mv} z~ uS}qS} yyrH M~a, PtM} Xz}Hq vSvS ySwSM} _ u}Mv} CS uS}qS PwSq cM} sScS PrS  2002 SM~ y |dv {rS YMv, rS} w} PsMc P| XsNvArc {2S h~Mi, rSMr ~ ~ P~SMc} hScA} PeMi cu rSZ vS _Z XsNvArc {2S} P{ScSAy~S c}Mr yM} <uSv YAsc vHAr ~ AyS~H PqH`A~} aw} cM}} zS} c{SMvS _} xM~ P|Mr }cSM}} Y c{My, rS S{S~ AtMr AvPAyMt} jv }cSM}} P| y c~Sq{~c P|SjvS YMi, P`M~S} aw} d}h c{SMvS MMi

u2 ~SeMr wSM}, }S{ PdMr wSM vS yM~ rS} cSi PsMc mScS AvM S{, |S} mScS} XzSy PvZ, rSMc AtM~ Ac {S P{Mm? \} ~, S{ P mScS AyAvMSe c}Mr wSM}, Y} rS} PsMc PcSva _c Atv }S{ hScA} PwMr wSM} _{v vHAr} xM~ PcSsSa cdva YAsc \7v MMi yM~ <{Sq PvZ, rMy SzSyrZ _Mr SM{} ~Sz Y} }SM{} Ar rS} {SMv Xr XsNvArc cS}Mq PrS }SM{} yMc {sv c}S \Ahr v, rSZ vS?

Xsh, YwAv |At YM{A}cS YAsc zSMy yMhM Xv} 10Cm }SjMc Pvv, P e YM} Atc PsMcZ PSc yS rc}S cr zSe {Sv tSA}( P}dS} vHMh YMiv PZ AMMyZ PSc, rS} <MrcCmMr y AjMrMiv Y} YAsc zSMy yMhM _AeM sScS <s{ tCm }Sj? <ArCmMr PcA} jH YM~ yM} XsNvArc vHArMr <r zSMy ~SzySv MMiv |>S}S r@SMt} ySt AtM ySAc ySZ PcA}Mc PzSm AtM~ PcA} Ayw~ PzSMm AjrMrv

rSZ yM} AyMt vHAr AvM CS uS}qS v, XsvHAr v, Xv PcSsSa _Z uM2} \} d>jMr My YAc \} wSaS |SMy YM{A}cS} zMeSM~ yMc {sv c}S }Sj`M~S <uSvr PtM} tAMq, |SMc a PtM} bible belt y~S  _Z }Sj`M~S XsNvArc zSMy wZSwt, {~r S{ _y PiSm {x~ M}} {C, S{SAjc zSMy }qH~, _y _dSMv ALSv P{R~yStH}S {SMj <y~ <zSyS~H YM{A}cS} e|M$} { _Z }Sj`A~ Ai~ tS<sS} {scMt} wM

m{S >S Whats the matter with Kansas yZM yqvS cM}Miv A}wSyA~cSv t~ Ayer cMc tMc _ X|M~} S{SAjc }qH~rS a u{H PeS>SA{Mc yyS} cM} cH zSMy rSMt} {sv cS cM} PxM~Mi, |Ata rSMt} XsNvArc c{Ah X|M~} SuS}q {SvM} SSMs} wA}wH _cmS PiSm \tS}q AtZ >SM} yZM} vSM{ P| cSvS }SMj} \MNd YMi, er cyiM} YM{A}cS} jSrH ySt{SuM{ rS} vS{ yS} yS} _MMi _cmSZ cS}Mq: oS}\ZMv} AyyrvySt ALuM{} wA}wH yM~ P }SMj YM2S~v h~Mi, AytS~M} wSn{ PsMc _Z AyCm rM~ AtMr My cXSMt} eqrSAc XAucS} AvM ~SZM Pvr AtMr AeM SMm} tMc PoM{SSCmc wSCm cSvSM} {MrS tAMq} _Z }Sj`M~S {sv SA}MMi, rS Y} AxM} PwMr { Av

rMy _Z }Sj`M~S PrS er AvyShMva yMcZ PzSm AtMAi~, ry PeSM} <S AjMr AeMAiM~v _ yS} rS M~ cH cS}Mq y AjrM~v? _} AwiMv tMmS {~ cS}q <s{r, _Z AvyShMv S Y} Z}Sc-|$ {~ tMmS Ay M t<SS, P|`M~S er yS} <SAc Ai~ vS

A&rHr, _ yS} er ySM}} r~vS <S 14 ~ P~Sc PyA PzSm AtMMiv, xM~ er ySM}} r~vS PzSmtSrSMt} dS PyMMi <S 14% _Z XArA} PzSmS}Mt} _cmS y X M~v wMySANAdr ALSv P{R~yStH PzSmtSrS}S yM} <uSv \wMtS cS~ P}Sz, }uS} }SjNvArc yA$} cS}Mq {SAcv }SjvHArMr |>S} hSqc~z zSy{Ar, er tyi} rq{~ UM} AejS`A~} {SuM{ _Z PqH} PzSmS}}S |SMr y dS _Z AvyShMv PzSm Ptv rS} jv Av}~ wA}{ cM}Miv

rSA~cSCm PsMc PtdS |SM KvArc {~MySu Y} S |>SMt} cSMi yMhM `Twq Ay (P{Sm PzSmS}Mt} 41% ) r>S}S AyS~ dS yMc PzSm AtMMiv XsvHAr Y} Z}Sc |$ |>SMt} cSMi yMhM `Twq Ay P{Sm PzSmS}Mt} 35%) r>S}S Ayw~ dS PcA}Mc PzSm AtMMiv wMyS PzSmS}Mt} dS PyA aS y AjMrMiv AMy c}M~ PtdS |SMy yM} jM} AwiMv KvArc {~MySu Y} SySt, tCm AyM} `T <S {Sv {Sv

PoM{SSCmc t~ _Z SM}} x~SLw _c ezH} YcMm} IdHv er tCm P<AMo* AvyShMv r>S}S PM}Miv _Z AvM Sr yS} Pc\ {Mv c}Miv PzSMm AjrMr PeM~ tM~} oSv AtMc PkS>cS \Ahr, Pc\ y~Miv vS, y>S AtMc |>S}S YSyStH r>S}S y~Miv, Ac vS cM} hw cM} yM sScS yMhM zS~, PcvvS y wvAvySAhr yS} YvM2 YS}S M _{v cScS}dSvS cT c}Myv, rSMr hS} yi} w} PtM} P~Sc PoM{SSmMt} }M cM}S yM~ oScMr YMyv Y} |>S}S Av}SSyStH r@S}S cSvSoS wSA PtaS} csS zSyMiv

P~dc ~v ~ Xy ZcvA{i-_ XsvHAr} Ac