Anandabazar Patrika

wA}h ...

84-} PhRcSMn 33-_} P<{

PS{yS} j8Atv rS} YMe {qS~ Pv yd Atv ySMt SScS}
AtMr }SAj M~v |S y a tHw PfS-_} cSMi

h}SA} PhRcSMn tS>AM {qS~ Pv Pc{v? _cmS PiS \tS}q PtaS |Sc Py~r~S P}SMo} ySAMr zS v2H} PrS~S wA}hS~Mc} PZ Ay}Sm PBS-Yw cSM{}S} S{Mv tS>SMvS PrAM} meyMe {qS~ Pv Ai~ yS} fM} wwcM}} hS}r~S} vrv ?SMm P iAy Sv wSM dSaS} fM} Pcv? PdMr PdMr AvMjMc PtAd, {qSM~} \} _cMhSd SA AvM

XsS <Mrc XArAs} cSMi Y} AvMjMc {Mv cA}M PtaS} tS PvZ {qS~ PMv} |S YMi, rS ~ S}Sq AvMjMc AvMj} XAUM} jSvSv PtaS

A{AiM~, u}vS |SZ vS Y}, AvMjMc SyMjf ySvSMr zS~ ~SMe vS
Ac XvSMv PrS |Sv A{AoS} SyMjf aS _SMr wSM}v Ac?
Ar y~y... YZ B~ aS* mJ Ay XSMmvMoo mJ Ac P| y jSeS _dvcS} XAzMvrS-XAzMvHMt} AfM}Z jm~S, P`M~SMc _AMZ hA~ YA{ PrS PdSMv vv-_vCmCm

cMcmS AjAv Xy _cZ YMi PiM~ cqS~ _y PiM~} P<A{cS}S _dva rS>Mc y yM~Z oSMcv 2}H P{M}S PM csS y~M~ _dva rS>} zS~ ~SMe Y} h}SA} PhRcSMn tS>AMa PhSMd SMS YMy AvM y~Mr wSM}v, _dva PrS YeS{H yiM}} PsMc _c yi} c{Z YMi y y Xy PyMMi _cmJ yi} tMc YMea PtdS M~ y~Mrv, rS>} Y} vH~M~SAMr} y _c SrS _ yS} P| Atv PtdS ~, P Atv cMsSwcsvmS _ }c{ Ai~:

YeS{H PS{yS} PrS h}SAMr wS PtMyv?
vS, vS, vS, vS, vS Y{S} PrS My{S PrA
PZ PrA Y} h}SA} {SkS{SAk tS>AMZ PySkS} PhS {qS~ PvMc

{SAvcySy
_cAtv <ArAtv-_ {{-_} ({{rS}) }SMr ySA vS Px}S AvM Y{SMc \|dv P~SMc <4 c}r, y~rS{ jSAv vS P PcSsS Ai~ YA{ ArZ jSvrS{ vS PmS zS~ ~SMeAv {SAvcySy} wM} jSvMr wSA} _cmS ZM}Aj KtAvMc <cSAr yMc P~dS rS>} _cmS AhCn PsMc <mS YMi Y{S} X~aM AyA yv  yZmSMr a@} {SmS PdSMvZ Ai~
cHM} {S? _Z P\| RSMc C} <MrcmS d>CmvSCm Ay _McySM} AvMj} SMr} {MnS }SdMr My rSMt} cH ~, vS ~, y Aci jSvMr My Y{S} PrS {Mv  _cAtv <ArAtv-_} PZ P{MCm, AcyS _cAtv XhSvc-_} PZ <Mx} eMO} ySZM} PcSsS { cSmSM, PmS Y{S} wM PcSva {MrZ jSvS Hy v {SAvcySy} AySmS Xv }c{ Ai~ AvMj} zSyvS`M~S tcMt} aw} hSAwM PtaS}a _cmS ySwS} Ai~ a@} PzrM} _Z P\| eqcMr P tM \Av \|S c}M~v, PmS PrS hSwSMvSZ
{SMv? YM} ZyMMv} _AvA{ Xy t Aww~-_ PrS oSS}Mc }iSS Mr  Y} \Av PtdSM~v, \|dv } iSMr hM~Miv oSS}, rdvZ rS>} P{M} ySet aZ zHY (`nSc}rS) _M y~Mi, _Z Ptdv, _}Sa YMi Y{SMt} M Y} PwiMv _ct~ P~Sc ZvSy Aj2SySt yM~ h>ShSM YA{ PrS wM} _cAtv yM~Ai~S{ {SAvcySyMc, jSMvv PrS, tJ P~SMc}S y~Mi, aZ P tM} P~Sc`M~S y YA~{AMv} Y{tSAv rSMr \Av AjMa c}M~v, rS YwAva Ac rSZ yM~v vSAc? y~~S{, YA{ PrS P~SMc \|S yM~, rSZ y~Ai rS} {SMv Ac {SAvc-{qS~ _cM yM YS AtM~a _Mc XwM}} iAyMr AyS }SMdv vS, PZ uS}qSmS _dva Ar? rAjMr} Avq <ASMc Ac _dva {SMvv vS {qS~ Pv? Y{}S AMdAia PrS a@} iAy PsMc \|{ AMdAi a@} iAyMra PrS XMvc vS y~S csS sSMc PmSa a@} cSi PsMcZ PdS Xsh \Av PmS ykM~v vS

SSt A{sShS}H _y ^Ac fmc
1982-} ySA~v Ax PxBzSM~ {qS~ Pv AyhS}c AyhS}c-hM} PhS}wSv AhcMc} P}MycS iAy} vSAcS PjSSv xvMmv P {M _c cAxMw xvMmvMc {qS~ yM~AiM~v, YwAv 1940-_a \|S AiM~v, _dva Pr{vZ YMivP}MycS xvMmMv} \} Ai~, {qS~, Z\ Y} Y AoA~S ~SS} 2007-_a {qS~ Pv AvMjMc rSZ zSMyv SSt A{sShS}H YwAv A{Ms yM~v? >S, yA~ PrS {SMk {SMk A{Ms <MSjvH {SMv C c}Mr PeM~ A{Ms y~Mr ? vS, C} { AvMj} cSMi YA{ Dq  C} Pzr} PcSva hA} \|At A{sShS} cM}, P tSA Y{S} v
	Ac _ }c{ hA} KrA} c}Mr PeM~Z PrS RS} AvMj} jHyMv} A{Ms`M~S \Mn YM? S> AvMj} jHyMv} A{Ms {Mv YM XyZ _cmS csS yA~ u}S \|Sc P{Mf pScS rS}S} P tmS SMvMmSA}SM{ {r} Atv `vMi A<S tStS (XAv~ hyrH) rSMc PtdMr _MMi {SsS} aw} YcS, k~ P{f Y} PmA~MxSMmS P~M PrS~S c{MwSAjm Mm tStS-PySv _{v _cmS A{~Mv} wA}MyM nS XAv~ y~Mr sSMc ySA} csS Xv PySMv} z}S SM}} csS csS`M~S \|dv XAv~ y~Mi, Y{S} {Mv MAi~ _ Pc? 
P{SmS hS{S, v z} ySr \|S} P<A{cMc AiAvM AvM AyM cM}Mi YM}c PySv, rS} SM}} Md} csS _r PxAvM y~S} cH YMi? _Z tmS Pcv c}~ ^Ac? cu aZ tStS YA{ yS>hMr PhMAi~S{-_} {rmS Py} cM} YvS} jv? YA{ ^AcMc AjaSS cM}Ai~S{ a yM~Ai~, _ iSS Y} cH c}y? ^Ac A{Ms y~Mr wSM}vAv CncZ {qS~a Ac rMc _SMr PwM}Miv? PwM}Ai PrS wtSArc-_} P tM w~Src PiM~Cm ySA AxM} _M PtMd {S {S}S PeMiv ySyS ( Ayjv zShS\|) rdv rSMc _cmS csS yM~v XAxM u{fm vS c}S} jv _cmS y Z c}Mr yM~Ai~ YA{ Z cA}Av csSmS ArAv _r Atv yM~vAv {r} {Md tS>AM sScS VH} SA \|SMr AyAQr vS , P jvZ ZAr{Mu wA~M} eSA YM ySyS PiM~Mc yM~v, \|Sa Ay Pz Xsh _Z ySyS PiM~} }SjNvArc {Mr} M {r AiM~v vS rS>} _Z r YS~ c}SmSZ _cmS XS{Sv A{Ms SSt A{Ms, <MSjvH A{Ms, XS{Sv A{Ms... y {M Ar y~Mr My _{v cH csS YMi!

A{nv, {{rS}, {eS

A{nvMc <s{ PtAd wMq Ax ZvBCm\Mm} cvMzSMcMv Y{}S ySZ yM YAi S{Mv _ct~ PiM~M{M rS}S AoM=S{S PvMy PtAd _cmS PiM~ pcMi ~GS, 2} ev, {SjS } P|mS PhSMd ~Se~ rS ~ P yS} YMe _cmS P{M} h~ PmMv At~, _cmS P{M} avS aS~ Y} rS} w} P| P{MCm} wSM y~, rS} PwMm Yg~ AtM PdS>hS At~ YA{ zSy~S{, yS, _ PrS Py Xz _ zS~ XAzMvrS MyZ XAzMvrS Mr PeM~ Xz Mr 

wMq} fmvSmS rS>} {Mv wM tyi} w}, {eS} {M PZ PiM~Cm} vS{mS rdv zM~ PeMiv Ac rSMc CncZ d>Mj Py} cM}AiM~v Y} zS}rH AMv{S PwM AeMAi~ A{nv hyrHMc

_Z {eSMrZ {{rS}Mca d>Mj Py} cM}v {qS~ cH PtdM~v {{rS} {Mu? yA$ aMt} ySAMr aMcZ Y{S} y PsMc yA${rH {Mv  PrS {{Mc _c Atv PoMc y~~S{, PSMvS, PrS{SMt} wSS y PsMc \>h ySA PcSvmS? a y~~ aMt}mSZ rdv HrcS~ y~~S{, P}Sj cSM~ iSMt \Mn t}jS rS~S AtM jS{ScSw dM~

P}SMt eS PwSSMr a cM}Ai~ rSZ A{nvMca P}SMt wAMAi~S{ PmS {SSMbSM} aMt} cS\McZ P{cYw AtMr Av

{{rS} rdv yi} cA HrcSM~} z}S P}SMt jS{S dM~ ArAv iSMt f}Mrv PRx XAzvM} jv XAzMvrS Mr PeM~ Av~ Mr  Xz Mr  {qS~ P AyS pAcM AtMr PwM}AiM~v yi} cA} P{MCm} Pzr}

Y} Yj? {S}y _dSMv ~S wMy 2SMv} A{nv hyrH? Pcv, wSyA~Mc} {S}, cSaSr~S wS} PmSa jSAv a} PtS v aMc P| zSMy yyS} c}S M, a rSZ c}Mi M PeMiv Ac {eS} A{nv? ZMy PrS AvZ Ac Y{SMt} {MrS {SvM} M _M~ YyS} sM~a \nMy YwvS}S rS} {SMv cCwSs}? _ yS} SA <SqMdS~S

XA{rSMz} c, P}dS} YytS}

r}b Ac Ad~SA} w} _cmS SScSM} XA{rSz yvMc <4 c}S MAi~, zMazSM} _mSZ rS>} <s{ iAy Ac vS? \Av SySAtcCmMc {Mv cA}M Ptv rAj v, {qS~ PvZ rS>Mc <s{ Pc Ptv, iAy} jeMr zyv PS{-_} zMazSM} P csS y~Mr AeM _dva {qSM~} PhSd hchc cM} aMn

Ac rS}w} PrS Y} cdva XA{rSz yvMc yyS} cM}vAv ArAv? vS a} {MrS hA} wSZAv cdva Xy a} PySu ZM Ai~

cH }c{? _c yS} a} _cmS iAy} cCm h~Mi cH _cmS cS}Mq YA{a PdSMv wSSwSA yM YAi rdv csS csS Y{SMt} _cM cSj c}S} csS \n~ YA{ y~~S{, a} { PcSsS? rdv XA{rSz Y{S yM~Ai~, {qS~tS, YwAv cdva Ac Y{S yM~ PtMdMiv? {SAvctSa cdva yM~vAv...

Xy P M|SMe} XMwS }SMdvAv zSvM}dS eMqv mSv PxSv rM~ {qS~ PvMcZ <USy AtMAiM~v, YwvS} iAyMr cSj c}Mr hSZ YA{ YwvS} Ay}Sm xSv P csS cMv {qS~ yM~AiM~v, Pcv A{Ms csS y~i Y{S} KrA} PcSva iAyZ PrS rA{ PtdAv rS iSS PrS{S} M cSj c}S Y{S} wM Hy v

Pcv? YM} t} P tAtv cm c}My PrS Arv Atv PwT AcyS wS}S`M AeM yM sScMy a zSMy YA{ cSj c}Mr wS}y vS PmS Y{S} <M|Sjca jSvr Y{SMt} keS PyMu P|r a} XAxM yMZ PrS P}dS PxSv cM}Ai~ Y{S

}SeH v, eS>uHyStH
csS} {SMkZ PxSv }SjM{Sv eS>uH} SEArc yZmS PjSeS cM} wMr hSv ArAv {SMv c~cSrS-71-_} {qS~ Pv c~cSrS-2007-_ wSMMiv XMvcmS? Y{}S eS>uH DMc, PvT DMc XMvc z~ cM}Ai rdv PmSZ <AS Ai~ _dv vrv zSMy {~SMv} t}cS} Y{S} _dv {Mv , eS>uH Ay}Sm AS~H {Sv AiM~v M}} PZ }SeH {SvmS} _dvcS} hS} wSmS PtMd }Se ? , Ac _dv YA{ XMvc SyuSAv {qS~ PMv}a rS M~ _Z {M SyuSv aS} t}cS} wM? AvMj} jvZ SyuSAv YA{ vS M~ YM}cmS z~ cM} Px~y
z~mS cH Ai~? Y{SM~ShvS c}rS{ vS rdv _dv {Mv  _mS vS M, amS M~ Pc{v r? y$Mty ({d{H y$Mty zShS\|) P\|{v {SMk {SMk YjcS~ yM~, Y{}S MrS z~ cM}Ai Ac Y{S} {Mv , AOSMv} hSM} PeSSMrZ a}S _cmJ {Ac~ cM} PxM~Ai~ Aci XSrS P}Md Y} rS}Z M\|Se hCmM AvMMi rq{~H}S _dva AvM YM~ y AciZ y{Sv aZ \M{} eSvmS} {MrS _Z ws \|At vS P , rMy Pc{v r... Y{}S yr{SvMc {SM~ShvS cA} y { Ac ZArSMca {SM~ShvS c}S \Ahr YZ cSMvf _zA} P{SM{* XrHMr} M yr{SvMc
Pc{v zSMy? rS>} c~cSrSa PrS wS~Mm Pe~ _dva y~Myv rSMc _~ PoS}SMoS? _ yS} hSwS SA _Z PrS Aci Atv YMe Py}c}Mc y~S MAi~, _S}MwSm PsMc rSj Py~ w>Ah A{AvMm PwR>Mi \|SMyv cMv a@} PhSd cwSM~ cH, vS yMGMra PrS _{v  vS! YM} PycySeSMv} ?SZazS}mS AtM PrS d cM} hM~ \|SaS \|S PmSZ y~Ai c~cSrS Pye _MMi Ac YMyemS cM{Av _cmJa... YMye Ac rS M~ rS>} cM{Mi? _Z P\| AOSMv} jv {Sv {S}S \|SM, yA$jHyH}S tM~ tM~ rSe cM}Miv }cSA} wt, ArAv PrS P {mS vH}y sScM~v Pcv? YA{ PcSva tM~} M yS AyM}SuH yA$jHyHMt} M _c{r ZAv rS M~ P\| Xv t~`M~S M\|Se PvMy, YA{ rS} AyM}SuH _dv \|S PtdAi jA{}S} cA{Cm} evmSZ Pc{v Xyr \|Ata yAk PuSS r~HwSrS PcSva t~Z v ry j PeSSS{H M anS Hy Av Ayv PcSgS} PrS vZ rS} {SMv {Svyt}At {qS~ Pv _ PM {r? vS {r Pcv My? YM~ YA{ cvAx\jo _r P~Sc {}~, vS {S}S ~? Mj Av}A aS} v <ArAtvZ AyAz7 cSeMj vSvS {rS{r wM \|qSAy$ Z Avt YAyM5q _y _cZ }c{ P}S{SB*crS _ y A{A~Ma PrS iAy Mr wSM}? YjcS~ P\|{v iAy M, rS} {Mu AvMjMc Y>mSMr ZM cM} vS Y} eOa PrS wSZ vS Ac M}} {qS~ Pv M~ PrS iAy r _Z A}-v2HS{ AvMZ rS M~ Pcv y~Miv eO PvZ? _mSa Ac _c u}Mv} }SjvHAr v? Sc} ~SMe M}} }SjvHAr Y} _dvcS} }SjvHAr} YcS jA{v rxSr _cmS }SjNvArc tM~} PwiMv ~SeS} jv P\| y t~ _cAr M... {Mv  P\|v ymSZ PzSMm} <bAr Ac PzSMm PrS y t~Z ~M cM~}Z AvjS wS sSMc {qS~ Pv rS M~ PcSv wS AySH? Ar, SyuSAv {qS~ Pv

Py~S PtmS SS P _ yS} {qS~-eHrS} cMsSwcsv
	SAo PsMc PyA}M PSS} fM}} t}jS AeM {qSM~} P<A{c~z P~Sv VH rdv P fM} YuMSS {qS~: eHrS, hM~S PdM AvZ Y} }Se PcSM}S vS eHrS: }SMe} Y} cH YMi? _r Py~S cM} dSaS! YA{ Y} cH y~y! {qS~: a}S _MAi~ csS y~Mr y~Mr PtA} ~ eHrS: PmS Y} PcSv Atv  vS PrS{S}! hSwSv-\MrS} h}SA} PhRcSMna YyS} PrAM} P<M{a

wA}h <cSAr  AvyS}