Anandabazar Patrika

Anandabazar Patrika - Editorial

13 YAv 1414 }AyyS} 30 PM9G} 2007

<y ...

{}S LwcsS

wmJSMc zS~MyMAi~ yAqMc} cMv <Sq AtMr ~ wmJSMc P| {Sj
SsMc rS cM}, PdSMv cH cM} Y} j8 PvMy LwcsS? _Z SsHv
{Mc yM PySMvSZ Ac Y{SMt} AvAr? A~dMiv
}ev hyrF

XO cAtv YMe} csS, _Z PrS cAtv YMe} _c PtM Ai~ _c yAqc, rS} Ai~ _c P{M PiS P{MmS y M \nMr ~Se~ Y} y Mr Mr _cmS { YM vS? |dv {Mv  vtH }HM}} PzrM}Z yZMi, }SuShS} c>A xmMi AvMj}Z X2M}, h@St a} PjSivS pS~Mi Y{S}Z jv hS} AtMc ySyS {S {S{S P{MS {SA AwA {SA{ AfM} sScM~a PhSd tMmS imxm cM} Pd>SMj, Pc Y{S} Ywv jv, Pc Y{S} XM XM ySjSMy y>SA? Y{SMt} cMv}a ~ PZ S~ Y}, a{S A{M~a Pe~ _c w}! }Sjw} v, yAqcw} v, Azv jSMr} _c wmJS rA~ c~{ v, P iAy Y>Mc cH _cmS fM fM, rSMc vSAc yM~ {S\ cMv PrS PMZ dv P iAy xMm aMn _cmS wtS vM hM, ytM~ |S, sM~ aMn, P P| cH tSTq!

AtAt, AwA, ySZ cMvMc yM~, wSe~ A~ rZ? Pc\ {SvMy PrS} _Z wSe~SA{? <SSMt} PtaS~`M~S Ax Ax cM} yM~, SyuSv cMv jSMvS vS a} cH MAi~, jSMvS vS rS} cH MAi~? cMv jSMv, _-y PjMv rS} ~Sz PvZ P PrS rS} {v Y} }H}Mc PjMvMi, P Y} z PjMv c}My cH? Sr wTM} eAt yM~, Ai, _ y cH? PyjSr PyfM} |SMy Y{SMt} P{M? P<{ YyS} cH? wA}q _cmS AyAv{ yAqc {vv Y} yAqc DMt} uS}q yMv} jv tCm {SvM} yv P{M} {v }HM}} ZM? Py PrS, {Sdc P{MA2 |At hS, eHr PSc y cM} c2v PSc zS}H YyS} cH hSZ? Ac P{M PrS Y{SMt} yyS} ~9H rSMc PrS PyfM} hM~ P|Mr PtaS |S vS PtaS~`M~S ~GS aS hSZ, rS~S`M~S zS}H

eOmS P|Mr LwcsS, rSZ YeM~ xSm~ sScMyZ _Z cMva d>Mj wS PZ xSm~ _cmS PiS ySMiZ P|v rS} <Sq PzS{}S, _cmS P{SySZ~ PtaSM~} _ wS Y} a wS cMv Y} wmJS csS  cMv yM~, hM~S Y{}S wSA~M |SZ PcSsSa wmJS yM~, PSvS{v, wSA~M y>ShS |S vS {SMj} Sr XMvc ~GS rS iSS Y{SMt} y YMnM}S _c wS} Y{}S PrS PcSva PtS c}Ai vS, wS~Sy Pcv? ySZ Cnc ykMy PtMdS Y{SMt} LwcsS AvMZ MrS _cmS tSTq SAxc iAy KrA} My eOmS wM}SmS jSAv vS rMy P ~SZvmS PrS ySZ jSMv, rS} w} rS}S Md SAMr Ah}cS~ Py>Mh }Z~ <SSt xSmMc cMv c<SMt, M}} Pu>SS anS }SUS t<SAM wmJS yM~, Pc<MtS vS y Cnc M |SMy

_ZmJc wM cH }c{ t{ YmMc YM Y{S} AhCnmS YjMc} oSMcZ _MMi PyItS} AhCn cSArMc} PtScSvmS \Mn AeMAi~ P w| wSS _cmS vrv cSMx dM~Mi _c Atv P AtMc P|Mr AeM Ptd~S{ t}jS _cmS \At wM} t<SAM cSArc jSAv vS, cH }c{ P|v ~Se~, <S wSA~M _MAi~S{ cAx dSaS Av rS} w} PsMc Y} PyItS} ySA |SaS M aMnAv YM~ PtScSMvZ PtdS r, ySA |SaS} XzS PrS Ai~ vS YjMc _M PtAd oSMc _cmS AhCn _MMi PyItS A~MdMiv, Pc{v YAi? XMvc Atv PtdS  vS wS}M~ _c Atv YA _cmS P~dS A~dAi~S{, PrSMc wSnS~S{, P Av PySu y yC AhCnmS Pc{v {v dS}Sw c}S rS} w} PtAd _cmS PiS P~dS, vS{: {}S LwcsS _cmJ t{ AvM ySAcmS YyS} wMr cT c}~S{

_c Atv M|Se A{M~ Pe~ YZMv} cSMi AeM PvSCm AtM _~ wmJS Y} cMv rS}S AyM c}Mr hS ~AcM hA}M v, PtM} y YZv P{Mv <Sy vSeA}cMt} {MrS {SsS \>h cM}, tS tSA AvM _} w} AyMa M Pe~ rSMt} MrS Cnc LwcsS} AyM} {MrS v, Pr{v P}SvSZ, SvSZ PcSsS, yAqcwTM}S Pm} PwM~ Xvs My P| PiM~Cm} ySAMr _M \n~ P{MCm AvMj} SMr P}>Mu dSaS~ ySZMc Sr{~S ySA v, Ac rSMt} X}{~ zM} \n~ Md _c Ah~Mr jSv~S XvM} iAy wmJS yM~, {v PrS X{vZ jSv~S |SMr YcSM} y YM~S vH~ PvM{ _M PrS{SMc \~r{S cM} PrSM~ cMv SM, Ac rS} {Mv} {Mu z, _r d CmcMy? AvMjMc P PySkS, a}S ykMy Y{}S PrS cS}a Ar cA}Av wSCnvH} {Md PSvS _cmS yS~S eSv {Mv wM rS}, Y{}S PrS Y} PiSm PvZ Y} PiSm PvZ P|dSMvZ sSAc PdSMvZ zS~ sScy

PyScS cMv jSMv vS, cr c{ yMk cr y _cmS cS ySAuM yMMi P mM~ AeMMi Sr wTM} eAt _Z P<{ YM~ PrS AyM(S {rS, DA US}c}Mq} ySc}q Ayw|U _r y S aZ Azv jSMr} wmJS}, yAqc w}D}SMc XwAy c}My P? XcSM}} Yg~ XMvc ~GS vM hM yM PcSmS~ Y} SAySAvH u} PymSMc, {S} PymSMc, M~ Pt PymSMc zM t{ YmMc YM cMv} cH My? wmJS yM~, z PwMS vS }SjS PrS yM~v r@S}S SuS}q {SvM} y Y{}S }SjS} YZv P{Mv AyySAr Y{SMt} Ar {SMv PrS }SjS}Z Xw{Sv cMv hS z}S PSc,  vS SSAv ySM _c Atv dy} YM {SM} y Xd, cMv |S {SMc PtdMr, Y} AxM} YM vS wmJS PfSM} _ PtS} PsMc a PtS} _Z X{Sr PsMc aZ PcSmS~ P{M~ SSAv PSMv {SvM} wSM t<SSMvS} y env YMi y Aci A~Md j{S Pt P Ac y PtA} M AeMMi Pv ~SZMv} wSM P{M~ wmJS} ~S, cMv PcSsS Pc\ jSMv vS LwcsSMr }SjcMvMc PrS ~AcMZ }SMd! {Sv wMs vSM{, yM~ SA hSZ Pcv {}~ wmJS? Pc {S}~ rSMc? cT  hSwSv \MrS} eOmS P<M{} LwcsS PsMc M aMn dMv} rt cSAAv tCm {Mv} zS~ySS} XAucSM}} YdSv P|v SA}M |S PZ hSMw

wAsyH oSMc YcS, P{f, ySrS, P}St, vtH, wSS SZMc yM~, z~ M AeMMi Y{SMt} Y{}SZ PrS _Z wAsyHMc Y}a 2} c}S} jv {SvMc PyMi AvMAi~S{ Y{}S rSMc yM~Ai P}St vtH P{f ySrS wSS SeM}} LwcsS iAy A~MdMiv Xyv nSc}, eSv PeMMiv }Ay ~S~v Ac _dv PrS {Sv {SMv Ay YcSM ySrSM {Mv fqS, SSMs, P~SMz v M |SM y _Z {H, _Z yAqc, _Z SHMt} AfM} PrS Y} LwcsS My vS LwcsS} jMv PrS ~SMe XHMy AyS, cMz} jM AyS XcMz} cSnSM{S |At y czMc wM}S AeM~ dS, rMy PZ wAsyH AtM cH My? hM~S Y{}S sM~ \Cn, rSw{SS ySAM _Z P<{Hv tAvSmSMc sSA~M AtZ

YcS P{f P}St yM~, vS _dva { YMi aZ Ptd _c {S, P| Azvu{H y\{SMc yMc PmMv AvMAi~, P| _dva cu y~Mi, Y} PcSva {SM} PcS~ P|v dSA~ vS  aZ P| _c t~ AcMS} AcMS}H zS~ySS} X{} PhM cS7S PhSMd _AeM YMi aZ P| PSeSv e~S imMi Aci P<R, P<RS, |S}S hS rSMt} PiM |SaS M P|v zS~ySS CmMc sSMc aMt} yS} jMvZ Y{SMt} sScMr My xSmc <SSt {vt |At wMh |S, rMy PzM |Sc, PjMe \nc vrv P<M{} h}

_Z yM~ P{f j~ k}S~, vtH \n~ xM~ wmJS} {rMt A{~yS} w} c~cSrSMc Xh~ cM} At~ yC Y} eS Xh~ wA~, Xh~ }cS}, Xh~ yyS PyScS }SjvHArAyt}S yk~Z vS cH M _ aMc t~, Awn y>ShS~, j~ j{S Y} c{S AvM r}jS {Sr~ Ac |S}S aZ wmJS Y} cMv} jv yMc} {Mu cS7S wM P}MdAi~, rS}S yk~, wAsyH {SvMc cS7S} }SjvHArMr AxM} YMr y~Mi y~Mi, AwrS, }SW, {Sj |At cS7SMc vS PhMv rMy y PzM |Sc cMv rS} y fM} yM Ac Pm} Pw~, ySZM} j~ ySMi, ySMi, w>SAh~ Y} CmcMi vS?

P~dS P Y{S} tMhSd zSMi PyItSMc PtdMr y ZM ~

* LwcsS {SMvZ PrS Dq cSOAvc eO