Anandabazar Patrika

Anandabazar Patrika - Editorial

9 XSq 1414 }AyyS} 25 vMzG} 2007

<y...

YMrZ wSM}v

Ac vSeA}c {SMj} _Z wA}M} }SjvHArcMt} YMr My PdS~S {Mv,
Xr Aci {M} jv AvjS t~{Mr} ]M) \Mn |At vSa YMv, _Z
wA}} PsMc }SjvHAr} _cmS vrv wSn AvMr wSM}v A~dMiv
P{H PfS

v2HS{ A} t~r AOSv AyAvMSe \Mt rA~{S P{R~ySt P}v w|SMr A}jaSv} wA~ {SaySt AS AyMS}q... ry c~cSrS} Xvr{ <uSv YM~Sh _Z {Mr? vSeA}c {Sj, AAz~ PSSZCm vSeA}c {Sj Y{SMt} crmS <MSjv, PcSv A{Ai~Cm vSeA}c {SMj} Cnc {d Y} PcSvCm v, ArcSM}} vSeA}c {Sj Ac _McZ yM~, vSeA}c {Sj Ac }SjvHAr} X vS }SjvHAr} ySZM}, X{c _y r{cMt}a _cM A{AiM~ AvM vSeA}c {SMj} _ cH AiA}, _r Atv Ac vSeA}c {Sj vSMc Pr~ AtM fM{SD~, vSeA}c {Sj AtM crmJcZ yS c}S Hy: <4 yd, AyAh Aci <4 jTA}, Aci XyS} Aci <M4} \M} PwR>iMvS} jv {vMv} <MSe t}cS}, Aci <4 XsHv csS} Pd~S, r}S {M~ yjvH _cAm <4 Ac P{RA~c UM} zSAyM PrSM~: P AtMv} {SA{Ai~Mc P| y }c{ }SjvHAr} PiS>Sh PsMc |Mt }S c}M~v XqcS}H}S, _Mr Ac vSeA}c {Sj vS{c ybCm} cS|cSA}rS yS~ vS c{~?

XsS, }SjNvArc &M5} wA}} PsMc P| vSeA}c {Sj _ zSMy AvMjMc A}M }Sd~, rSMr Ac AyM}SAurS} PjS} XMvcdSAv cM{ Pe~ vS? A Aw _{ _} AyTM$ P| PSMz} <cS fm~ PZ {SA{AiM~, }SjvHArMc ySt AtM Ac PZ AyM}SAurS ArZ Hy? A{AiM~} X }SjvHAr} XAz{Sv Ac P w| A Aw _{ PcZ SS| c}~ vS? rq{~ cMM} t}Sa |At vSeA}cMt} wSM wS P{~SMrv, Xr yA AMMy, rS M~ |$mS Ac ZAr{MuZ fvMfS} YcS} Pwr vS? ~qH, <uSv AyM}SuH PvH Ac _ <4 PrSM~vAv, <sM{ {SA{AiM~ XMq} ZS <cS c}M~a wM} XvMt} XvM}Su {Sv cM} X SzSyA$ Y{|StS AvMjMc A}M AvMMiv YMw Xy PSvS PeMi XvSv PvrSMt} {Md P|{v, XH{ hMSwSuS yM~Miv, A Aw _{ AyM}SuH }SjvHAr} _Mr Ay}Sm Ar ~ Ac AyM}SuH }SjvHAr} SSs iSSa _dSMv _c ezH}r} zSyvS} csS YMi }SjvHAr} wA}} PsMc AvMjMc A}M P}Md vSeA}c {Sj Ac }SWH }SjvHAr} PM PcSva `Twq zA{cS wS~v c}Mr wSM}?

AymS PeS~M{M~ jm iSSMr M~ vSeA}c {Sj ybCm} hA} PdS~ }SdS t}cS} Y{SMt} rS} YMe yM~ PvaS |Sc tMmS csS _c, }SjvHAr y~Mr XMvc Aci PySkSMvS |S YwSrr }SjvHAr y~Mr Y{}S uM} AvD _cmS AvAt rx a AvAt XSMjS} {SuM{, }SWH {rS} XMv P| <ArM|SAerS{~c t~H }SjvHAr cSj cM}, rS} csS tZ, _Z XMs P| }SjvHArPc Y{}S yAk, aZ A{AiM~ rS} Ry |sSHy yjMv} {Mu _c Ay}Sm AyMyhvS Ai~ Pcv? PcvvS, {rS} }SjvHAr} wA}M}} wSSwSA _cmS S{SAjc wA}}a PrS YMi vSeA}c {SMj} <s{ tS Ac PZ S{SAjc wA}M}} cSMiZ Pa Y} _c }c{ }SjvHAr, _y <S y PMZ {rS} }SjvHAr} Ac   |At rS} AwiMv sSMc aZ S{SAjc }SjvHAr} ezH} a yS {sv _Z S{SAjc AyM}SAurS} M }SjNvArc AyM}SAurS} _cmS fAv Dc Swv c}S t}cS}, Ac AyAz7 cS}Mq 2007 SM~} wDZ{yM PmS tL M t<SAMMi PZ cS}MqZ vSeA}c {Sj _Z w|SM }SjvHAr PsMc AvMjMc Sr cM} rM~ _cCm Y~StS {|StS uS}q cM}Mi, _c Y~StS Av{SqcSMj} hvS cM}Mi

vSeA}c {Sj a {rSMcD4c }SjvHAr} Dc Pc{v aS \Ahr, rS} PcSva u}SyS>uS Av{ PvZ vSeA}c {Sj ~ {SMj} yd PAq} yd PeSH} {SvMc AvM Srr iS>tAyHv _c j{SMr rS} {Mu PcSva }SjvHAr sScMra wSM}, vSa sScMr wSM}, <SsA{c zSMy vS sScSmSZ tb} rMy XMvc { cS~M{ vSeA}c j{SMr PsMc }SjNvArc j{SMr j8 AvMr wSM} }SjvHAr} M DMc} Atc PsMc vSeA}c {SjMc Xr Arv zSMy PtdS |S:
1) |S} AyM PcSva }SjNvArc rx PvZ,
2) cTMr |S} AyM PcSva }SjNvArc rx sSMc vS, Ac P| M{ {M} M }SjNvArc rx KrA} cM} PrSM~,
3) <s{ PsMcZ |S} AvAt }SjNvArc rx a \M YMi \tS}q PtaS |Sc
1) {SSv{SM}} SEArc AyMSz YM2S~Mv AS~H _c <ArySt Ai~, Ac PcSva AyM }SjvHAr} iS>t Ai~ vS PyR$ Az iSiSH {uAy {jHyH, AyAz7 u}Mv} {Sv _c M }SMW} t{vvHAr} <ArySt c}AiM~v, Xsh cS}aZ jSvS Ai~ vS zAy }SjvHAr} YcS} <cS} cH aS \Ahr rS} jv Ac PZ AyS~ AyMSMz} {~ cM{ |SAv
2) 1885 SM~} j8~M jSrH cMM} {Mu jSrHrSyStH {SvAcrS} <cS Ai~, P| jSrHrSyStMc y~S P|Mr wSM} }SjvHAr} _cmS Y~eS uS>h vSeA}c {SMj} Xvr{ x{ AMMyZ rSMc Y{}S PtdMr wSZ {M} M M, PZ YyiS }SjNvArc iS>t M{ _c eCnr }SjNvArc tM~} Lw Pv Y~eS (loose) =Smx{ wA}qr  MwS <ArSMv
3) X{ <MtM} vSeA}c {Sj YM2S~v |dv X{ eq S{ wA}Mt wA}qr ~, yS (SAy cje{ YM2S~v PsMc j8 Av~ (SAy {M7S cje{ (Ao _{ Pc) a X~ ZAS Y7S (SAy {M7S cje{ (_ YZ _ Ao _{ Pc), rdv PtdS AeMAi~ Y}a er _y XAvyS| LwS}: P y PM <s{ PsMcZ vSeA}c {SMj} YM2S~Mv} }SjNvArc hA} a tSAy Ai~ , SHcr

AyAz7 }cM{} env, AyAz7 \M <ArCmZ Ac vSeA}c {Sj _} \tS}q AAz~ PSSZCm} {~ KyAZ ~, _cmS zS{SvrS (fluidity) YjMc} t cS~ vS sScMr wSM}v cS~ A|Av YMyv, rS>Mc MrS YMe cdva PtdS |SAv t}S y AyM _c{r aS t}Sv, PcSva _cCm AyMa wM}SwA} _c{r vS Mr wSM}v! Y} _Z X{rS} {MuZ PsMc |S {Sj a }SjvHAr} vSvS &M5} rc a {SuSMv} HSyvS xM~ }SjvHAr} M P|Se vS }SdS} XAucS} Ac P AtMv} {SA{AiM~} PsMcZ |S! _{v fmvS YMea fMmMi zAyMra fmMy

_} wM}a _cmS csS YMi vS oScS} XAucS} aZ vSeA}c <ArAvAuMt} AvZ Ai~ Ac vS oScS} A$S rS>}S AvM~v Pcv? YM~ P AtMv} {SA{AiM~} {Mu A Aw _{ _} <Ar P|{v yjMv} _cCm <r ySrS Ai~, Pr{vZ Ai~ rq{~ a cMM} <Ar _c wM}S ySrSa ySrSCm ~: cHq t~HrS a M|Sew}Sq vHArHvrS }SMj} }cSM}} M M AyM}SuH }SjvHArMca _r tHq cM} AtMMi P| PZ tHqrS} M vSeA}c}S AvMjMt} jSMr hSZMiv vS _r AyS~ dc vSeA}c }cSA} tM~} PSShSM}} <Ar rH Ay}Se Mxa P| AyM}SuH }SjvHArMc Ywv cM} AvMr wS}M~v vS, _} {Mu Ac _c PfS} XSrS YMi

_cmS YSa YMi vrv ws KrA} aS} YS XvSv XMvc PM} {MrS _dSMva vSeA}c {SMyM} {u PsMc wM} j8 AvMr wSM} vrv AyM}SuH }SjvHAr Ac rS} <SsA{c tS vSeA}Mc} v, PvrSMt} rS>Mt} ykMr My, vSeA}c}S rS>Mt} cSMi YMyv vS, rS>Mt}Z vSeA}cMt} cSMi PwR>iMr My P| cHqrS, AyuSySt rS>Mt} <Ar AyM& KrA} cM}Mi, rS AvM wvAyMyhvS c}Mr My _{v wA}AAr KrA} c}Mr My, P|dSMv }SjNvArc PvrS Ma yA vSeA}Mc} XAucSM} _cCm A{AiM~ YMr hSZM~ Xv}S P|v AyS c}Mr wSM}v P|, Xr Aci {M} jv _Z y }SjvHArc AvjS t~{Mr} ]M) anS} {rS }SMdv 2007 _} vMzGM}, tzSe, PZ AyS SuS}q vSeA}Mc} PvZ PvZ yM~Z |rmS Hy yq}Abr }SjvHAr} ySZM} sScMrZ rS>}S wi2 c}M~v \Av rMc} x}SA `ArSAc YM~i Ao rcAz~ P|{v Mhrv vSeA}c a }SjvHAr} Dc PySkSMr AeM yM~AiM~v: He looks upon political authorities with an eye of mistrust and anxiety, and claims its assistance only when he is unable to do without it.