Anandabazar Patrika - Editorial Feature

21 KySd 1415 }AyyS} 4 P{ 2008

<y ...

{}SCnMt} PhM Y{}S Ac
{SrzSS c{ zS~ySA?

|At rS vS-Z My, rS M~ _dSvcS} }cS}, AyM}SuH w
yS~S zSS DMc _r Xv{v Pcv? <4 rM~Miv
vH~ eMSwSuS

yS~S iAy? c~cSrS} _cCm {SBM=i iAy: PtySA }S

_ yS} {S}SMW Py cMcCm AMv{S M~} ~SZM PdSS |SMy cu Avic w}MvS u}Mv} _ctH ~`A~Z v, _dvcS} k<S-hchMc {SBM=i`A~a wMy _Z tSaS} YarS cS}q dy  Aci Atv YMeZ }Sj }cS} PsMc _cmS PvSCm jSA} c}S MAi~ _Z {M{ P|, AMv{S ~`A~} ~SZM wvvrv c}S} { yiM} Xr hS}Cm {}SCn Ax PtdSyS} r {SvMr My _ }c{ _cmS PvSCm PtaS} w}Z }cS} fA{M wMAv, PdSvcS} \w-{d{H Y} Y} wSAm~ AvMj \MtSe AvM PtdMr PhMAiM~v AvMt crmS cS|c} ~ XySu ~-{SA~cMt} ArAv _c {S {a AtMAiM~v r@SMt} yy jSvSyS} jv XMvMc wSSZ PtAv, \}a PtAv _ yS} rSMt} ~SZM ySAr~ My

Pc\ Pc\ {S{~S P{Sc{S ySuSyS} PhS c}Myv MrS, Ac AyM Aci }SS My yM~ {Mv  vS cS}q, zSS} ySwSM} YMeZ _ }c{ _cmS A$S YZvr M AeMMi P }SMj} {U M~ {}SCn zSS} _cCm w XSyAc `j}SAr {SA~cSvS} _cCm y AytS~ _Mr YwA jSAvMAi~ uvH `j}SArMt} ~, PdSMv cu `j}SAr iS}SZ wMy, rS}S {}SCn AdMr ySu My Pcv? _Z AvM {S{~S ~ PZ {S{~S A<{ PcSm w| eS~ A<{ PcSMm} Py| PsMc AvMt _~, {S}SW }cSM}} _Z vHAr Dq YZvr zS}Mr} P| PcSva vSeA}c PtM} P| PcSva X|M~ yyS c}Mr wSM} Ac Pc\ yySM} }SMj} zSS a Ar PsMc Ay| sScM~ P wq vSeA}c XAucSM}} P|Se  vS

_dSMv rSA{~vSY|} tS mSvAi vS _ AyM P }SMj} vHAr yjvAyAtr rSA{~vSY|Mr |dv P| }cS}Z sScc, }cS} a AyM}SuH wM} {Mu |r ~S~AZ PSc, zSS} <M4 ySZ _c{r PdSMv PcSva AMv{S M~ rSA{~ iAy PtdSMvS vS M~, AcyS M~ rSA{~ zSS yAjr M~ }cS} yS }SjNvArc t~`A~Mc PcSva yyS q c}Mr My vS, jvSuS}qZ _M AwM~-h{cSMvS z PtdSMy rSA{~ zSS} `Ar XMvc <ShHv, rjSr v, \} zS}Mr} PcSva zSS} MZ Ay2{S A{~ PvZ, PZ jvZ rSA{~}S AvMjMt} zSS a Ar DMc
PyA-PyA }qH~ PrS MrZ wSM}

Ac {S}SMW} M PrS rS v {S}SWH zSS} M AA2} dy _cmS rxSr PvZ, P|{v yS~S} Ma PvZ {S}SWH h~DM} XMvc c~Sc~HZ AA2 h~DM} M jAr, P|{v yS~S} ry {S}SWH}S rSMt} zSS a h~D }Mq} ySwSM} rc a |tH~ Y}, yS~S Pcv cuZ f{SM }?

<MrMc} cSMiZ rS} {SrzSS XAr A< zS}Mr _r`A~ zSS; y zSSZ }S c}S Y{SMt} jSrH cry _y _ csSa XyZ {Sv P|, zSS} Av}} wA}h|S t}cS}, vZM~ j~-A|Mv} XzSMy eSMi} {MrS zSS c a AyHq M |S, Xv zSS} {Mu ~Hva M P|Mr wSM} P| }SMj} zSS, PZ }SMj} }cS}McZ PrS P zSS} \7v a wA}yuMv} jv |tySv Mr My cvSmc yS \}<Mt PrS yS~S AvM {SsS fS{SMy vS! P|-y }SMj <uSv zSS tArvCm; P|{v, kSdM, PdSMv yS~S a >SarSA~} {rv <uSv zSSMca SHcAr PtaS} tSAy \MnMi r cS}Mq vZM~, yd {Sv {SrzSS S}SMy

wDZ{yS~S yS~S zSSzSH} dS rc}S AiSA jv ry _dSMv \t zSSMc SHcAr AtM _cCm zS~ tS SAwr MMi _ }SMj AA2 PdS} XMvc yyS YMi, AA2-{Su{ ~ YMi, y Pc4H }cSM}} XAxM AA2 PdS ySurS{~c, AA2 \y , dy zS~ csS Ac ySZ yS~S AdMy vS?

yS~S h~DM} KtvtS cSmSyS} jv _ }SMja y AMv{S M~ yiM} Xr cMc S yS~S AMv{S ySurS{~c c}S} <USy \MnAi~ XMvc YMeZ }cS} PcSva yyS q cM}Av _ <USMy} AyTM$a t}c{ csS PSvS AeMAi~ ySurS{~c @mSMrZ XMvMc} YwA ~-{SA~c}S yySH, r@S}S PcSv Ax PtdSMyv AcyS PtdSMyv vS, rS AvMj}SZ Cnc c}Myv r@SMt} aw} r hSAwM PtaS My Pcv? _mS yA-SSuHvrS} wA}wH _Z AhSMc y~S P|Mr wSM} SSuHvrS @Cm} ytjM{} Ppc} jHyMv} y PMZ SSuHvrS} }c{Mx} YMi {t AyMrSa PrS SSuHv yySH, rMy Pcv vSyS~cMt} aZ PvS} (y AyA c}S |S vS? AhAcS yyS oSS}}S SSuHv, ry Pcv ezyrH} XjSr SMv} A~-Avq Py-YZAv? PwSSc AvyShMva cM~} SSuHvrS sScS \Ahr, Ac PdSMva Ac _cmS H{SM}dS mSvS PvZ? PcSva PwSSc w}MrZ |S} ZM cM} vS, rSMc aZ XyS }SjwMs PyM}SMvS} SSuHvrS Pt Ac PcSva {Sj? ZrSAt SSuHv AhS, yA-SSuHvrS} M M Pt-cSM~} \wM|SeH Aci vHAr P{MvZ zrS} XeAr  Xv XMvc PtM u{ DMc P|-PcSva {rS{r y c}S |S, Y{SMt} PtM |S vS, _mS {SvMrZ  }S}A, tSS-SS{S} k>Ac AvM ySc SSuHvrS?

A&rH YwA, y AMv{S M~ yiM} cMc S yS~S AMv{S <tv YyAc (ySurS{~c @Cm} ytM~) c}S |SMy cH cM}? Xr yS~S AMv{SZ PrS KrA}  vS yiM} cMc S Aci AMv{S ~ Ac x<ScS wM sScMy? _mSa AvrSZ c-|A yS~S Ax~M{ _dv A<M*} dS c{ ; M~} dS ySM~ A<*a ySMr wSM} rS iSS, {A} HSyvS AvDZr sScM~ vrv vrv <M|Sjc}S Y}a h~D Av{SMq _AeM YMyv _dv _cmS yS~S AxM} {A} jv <M|SjcMt} P| cH wA}{Sq vSMjS~ Mr , rS A5 yA}S jSMvv, ~S <cS cM}v vS {S}SMWa yS~S} r~vS dy PyA h~D AvA{r  vS Ac y P<SeM} t}jS \8 M~ PdSvcS} h~DM} dS ySMy, XMvc c~Sc~H cSj wSMy, _Z ySAqMj vrv } |S} My, _Z YSMrZ {S}SMW, PdSvcS} y M~ {}SCn AMv{S YyAc c}S} yyS PvaS MMi yS~S Pcv rS wS}My vS? cHM} jrS?

Xv PcSva zSSMc YfSr vS AtM, wDZ{yS~S} y AytSrMv yS~S AS YyAc c}S} XMvc AtMv} tSAy wDZ{y }cS} Pcv P{Mv AvM vS, rS Y{SMt} yA$} Xe{ Xv XMvc }SMj} tSZ PrS YMi, _{vcH Y{SMt} wSM} }Sj aASMra Y{SMt} }cS} _ ySwSM} {Md c~w _>Mm YMi, AyM}SuH w zSS AvM {SsSZ fS{S vS wDZ{yM} vS{ yt~ cM} cu yMt }SdS} <USya PrS~S MAi~ _c { _dv rS} aw} uM~S jM{Mi cMc w}r cMc jv }SjvHArAyMt} cSMi _Z < \Swv cM} cMvAi, >S _mS c}S \Ahr, |A YMi; Ac... _ }SMj} <uSv yySH}S XySgSA~, r@SMt} XMvMc} {MdZ AtAy wA}S} yS~S PSvS |S, PiM~M{MMt}a yS~S AdMr YwA YMi yM~ {Mv  vS, rMy? aZ Ac @Cm y cCnv!